Discussion Forum

Problem on Feb. 22, 2018

 
 
Picture of maddy ren
Problem on Feb. 22, 2018
by maddy ren - Tuesday, March 27, 2018, 6:11 PM
 

Dear Areteem teachers, Could someone please explain the posted solution for the problem on Feb. 22, 2018? I have a different answer. Thank you so much!

 
Picture of David Reynoso
Re: Problem on Feb. 22, 2018
by David Reynoso - Wednesday, March 28, 2018, 11:09 AM
 

Hello Maddy! The way the problem was worded lead to different answers so it was updated. All students that had submitted an answer to the problem were awarded the points. 

Picture of maddy ren
Re: Problem on Feb. 22, 2018
by maddy ren - Wednesday, March 28, 2018, 12:05 PM
 
Thank you, Mr. Reynoso, for your reply. I didn't misunderstand the original problem. The previous posted solution (see the screenshot I attach here) says 'Notice the "sculpture" is made of exactly 4 of these corner pieces'. I think it should be 8, which leads me to a different answer. Thank you again for your time to look into this.


Picture of maddy ren
Re: Problem on Feb. 22, 2018
by maddy ren - Wednesday, April 4, 2018, 3:27 PM
 

Could someone confirm please? Thank you!

Picture of David Reynoso
Re: Problem on Feb. 22, 2018
by David Reynoso - Wednesday, May 16, 2018, 4:56 PM
 
Hi Maddy. We made a drawing of the problem using Geogebra. You can find it here. If you rotate the figure you can notice how the spheres touch the cube in $2$ points each, and the "plaster" around them is all connected, so it made no sense to "remove the outer edge" as the original problem asked (that would have resulted in removing ALL the plaster, so no sculpture in the end :/). The way the problem was reworded afterwards may not produce a nice sculpture, but at least has a unique answer.