This solution assumes the radius of the cylinder to be 1, but, when someone takes this as x, there is an x^3 in the volume and an x^2 in the surface area. These are both equal to 1 in the example given, but, wouldn't this ration change as the dimensions change?

## Discussion Forum

### June HS Question 1

Hey Jeffrey!

You are correct, if the radius of the cylinder is $x$, the volume would change by a factor of $x^3$ and the surface area by a factor of $x^2$, thus the ratio of those would change by a factor of $x$. We will update the scores so that question does not count towards the final score. Thanks for letting us know!